Commodities Corner: Why OPEC+ effort to stabilize oil prices points to potential supply deficit unless shale output rebounds


Oil has made a huge comeback from the historic dip for U.S. benchmark prices into negative price territory in May, with the recovery in large part due to a production-cut agreement by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and its allies, and involuntary output reductions in the U.S.

The rebound in prices is a “positive development for the market and a signal that we’ve probably moved through the worst of the underlying imbalance” in the oil market, says Greg Liebl, senior investment strategist at Parametric Portfolio Associates.

Expectations that OPEC and allied non-OPEC producers, collectively known as OPEC+, will extend current production cuts of 9.7 million barrels per day past their expiration at the end of June have contributed to oil’s price gains.

Without an extension, the cuts would taper down to 7.7 million barrels per day starting on July 1. OPEC+ will meet Saturday via videoconference. The group is expected to finalize a plan to extend current output cuts through July, according to The Wall Street Journal.

That follows an 88% climb for West Texas Intermediate oil futures in May, the largest monthly rise on record. Prices CLN20, +5.18% have more than doubled since the negative $37.63 a barrel futures settlement on April 20. At $39.55 a barrel on Friday, however, they were more than 35% lower year to date. Prices on Friday got an added boost as upbeat U.S. jobs data for May fed expectations for a further recovery in energy demand.

Liebl says it’s important to remember that despite the rise in May, WTI is still lower than in early March, just before Saudi Arabia and Russia called off their deal to cut output. Prices settled around $46 the day before news of the deal’s collapse.

“The majority of companies in the industry don’t make money at these low prices, and even Russia and Saudi [Arabia] need oil to be higher than $55 a barrel to balance their budgets,” says Alissa Corcoran, analyst and director of research at Kopernik Global Investors. “These low prices aren’t sustainable for any meaningful period of time, which has posed very attractive buying opportunities for us.”

She says that prices would need to be at about $75 to incentivize new oil supply, and they are far from it. “We find the best investment opportunities when the price is significantly different than the incentive price, as is the case with oil today,” she says.

An OPEC+ decision to extend production cuts may, however, cause supplies to tighten too much before year end. “The rolling over of OPEC production cuts will cause the global oil market to fall into severe deficit by the fourth quarter,” says Leigh Goehring, managing partner at investment firm Goehring & Rozencwajg.

U.S. shale production may see a “huge fall-off” starting in the third quarter, Goehring says. Combined with a continued rebound in demand, that would result in “huge inventory drawdowns” by the middle of the third quarter that will accelerate into the fourth quarter.

“Oil prices will continue to surprise to the upside as the year progresses, very much like they have surprised most people over the past 30 days,” says Goehring.

Still, higher prices may eventually lead to more shale production, and the path for demand remains uncertain.

“There is a risk that production from North American shale creeps higher, responding to a partial recovery in crude prices, while the oil demand recovery is expected to slow down by September…in the seasonal weaker period,” says Chris Midgley, global head of analytics at S&P Global Platts.

“There is also the risk of secondary waves of [Covid-19] infection, posing a significant risk to oil demand” and prices, he adds.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.